Verizon faces ‘lose-lose’ situation amid aggressive AT&T promotions, analyst says in downgrade

See additionally: AT&T earnings, revenue rise as company sees some recovery from COVID-19

That’s not excellent news for Verizon
VZ,
-0.94%,
in response to Moffett, as sustained promotions from AT&T might pressure different wi-fi carriers to comply with swimsuit. Verizon’s subscriber tendencies have suffered as the corporate adopted a “wait-it-out” strategy to AT&T’s promotions to date, however now the corporate is in a predicament, he mentioned.

“[I]f Verizon now concludes that AT&T’s promotional stance is to proceed, they’re confronted with a lose-lose alternative,” he wrote. “Proceed to face by and their development will endure additional. Reply, and their development will get better, however their profitability will decline. There are not any good choices.”

There are already indicators that AT&T’s strategy is resulting in decrease wi-fi costs elsewhere within the broader business, which might pose extra issues for Verizon. Comcast Corp.
CMCSA,
+0.70%
not too long ago lowered costs for its household plans, which means that the corporate’s “limitless service is now cheaper than, or not less than on par with, Verizon’s service for each measurement plan,” Moffett wrote.

He nonetheless has questions on whether or not Comcast can generate income by its new pricing, and in regards to the “sturdiness” of AT&T’s margin efficiency given its promotional stance, however he additionally worries that “a interval of higher aggressive depth now appears extra seemingly.”

Accordingly, he downgraded Verizon’s inventory to impartial from purchase Tuesday, arguing that a number of elements of the bullish view he specified by a December improve now not completely apply.

For one, whereas he continues to assume that Verizon will be capable to develop common income per person (ARPU) this 12 months by driving upgrades to limitless plans and getting subscribers to pay for Disney+ by a partnership association, there may be additionally “higher threat of a pressured response to AT&T’s promotionality that would harm ARPU.”

Verizon shares are off 0.9% in Tuesday morning buying and selling.

Moffett sees different causes for hesitation as nicely. Again in December, he had anticipated Verizon to get “extra spectrum for much less” in an important public sale for mid-band wi-fi spectrum, a prediction that “couldn’t have been extra flawed” as aggressive bidding within the public sale drove up costs and left Verizon with a “badly battered” stability sheet.

Moreover, though Verizon is a “low cost inventory” nonetheless, he sees it as “much less so” now that the corporate had to spend handsomely on the spectrum wanted to construct out its 5G community. And even with Verizon’s massive spectrum hauls, it is going to take time earlier than the corporate can entry the brand new spectrum and incorporate it into its community. That provides a bonus to T-Cell US Inc.
TMUS,
-0.16%,
which already had a considerable quantity of mid-band spectrum earlier than the public sale and has begun deploying it.

Learn: AT&T’s transition to 5G means huge upfront costs. And it needs HBO Max to succeed.

“AT&T lags not solely T-Cell, but additionally Verizon, in densifying their community for 5G,” Moffett continued, and he opted to maintain his promote score on AT&T after some consideration. Regardless of expectations that AT&T faces easing comparisons over the following six months, he voiced “considerations about AT&T’s weak positioning in 5G” and “reservations about their earnings high quality/accounting modifications in Q1.”